That one time I was an ex-vegan
It seems there are a breadth of vegan bloggers who have made their way to the ex-vegan blogger category lately, due to the fact that they equate their vegan diet with anorexia, orthorexia, or other forms of unhealthy restriction. As is to be expected, a discourse is taking place -some of which is healthy and supportive (Thanks, Sayward!), and some of it, as you can imagine, is not so much.
Veganism and ex-veganism are topics that are near and dear to my heart. I am vegan. I have struggled with orthorexia, anorexia, bulimia, and compulsive exercise myself. I too, at a time, was an ex-vegan.
I was a freshmen in high school when I saw my first “Why Vegan?” pamphlet, and the pictures contained within would not erase themselves from my brain. I had already been vegetarian for about a year, and decided that it was only logical to set a date to go vegan. (October 30, 1998 for the record!) I was 14 at the time, and this was long before unhealthy food behaviors entered my stratosphere. (that didn’t happen until age 24.)
I remained vegan through the worst of my eating disorder. I remained vegan through the beginning of my recovery, despite the recommendations of my doctor, my therapist, and various support group members. I knew that, without a shadow of a doubt, one could have a positive relationship with food on a vegan diet, that it wasn’t all about juice cleanses and water fasts. (Hell, at this point you could replicate the standard american diet while remaining vegan- not that I recommend this!) My veganism didn’t shake through getting an eating disorder, nor did it shake through obtaining a healthy weight for my body size. My veganism shook when my stomach seemed to stop working.
I have written before about my struggles with IBS, and my regimen to take care of my ever-sensitive guts. Things are good with my belly, now- great in fact. But I want to tell you that at a time, I felt completely hopeless.
When one is drastically underweight, and does the work to get healthy, it is a total mind trip. Your body changes and feels totally foreign. Additionally, digestion tends to be tough. This is true for a lot of people and for me, it was no different. In my recovery, I was absolutely plagued with intense bloating (to the point where I was asked if I was pregnant ALL THE TIME. ) Every time I ate something it was like it attacked me from the inside out. Bloating was just the beginning, and it only got worse from there.
Although I had been in recovery for about four years, I was starting to fear food in an entirely different way. Beans became off limits, and grains too- both because every time I ate them I had instant pain at best, and diarrhea at worst. I started looking into a raw vegan diet because I had heard from many different sources that it was wonderful for digestion. I tried it, and it was even worse than a cooked vegan diet full of grains and beans was. I had a multitude of tests done to determine my problem, and when I was diagnosed with IBS, I was almost disappointed. IBS seemed like no big deal, so why was it ruining my life?
I started to feel like everything I ate needed to be incredibly cooked and pureed in order for me to properly digest it, and even when I did that, I sometimes STILL had flare ups. I became anxious and withdrawn, embarrassed to go out with constant stomach trouble, and was downright lonely. For all my healthy eating advocacy, I sure wasn’t feeling very good.
In September of 2012, I joined my crossfit gym, and of course, was introduced to the idea of eating Paleo (although to my coaches credit, they ALWAYS supported my choices, and were never dogmatic about eating Paleo or anything else). Despite this, one of the (many) health claims about a Paleo diet is that it just so happens to be awesome for digestion, so it piqued my interest. I knew I wouldn’t be willing to eat meat, but I became intrigued about the idea of adding eggs to my diet and going Paleo as a vegetarian.
After an intense amount of research, I decided that I would add pasture raised eggs to my diet, and only after I was SURE that the hens had a good life. (I used this egg score card to determine which companies I might call to ask questions to). Sadly, I told my friends I wasn’t vegan anymore. Everyone I knew had seen me slowly subtracting foods from my diet in an effort to feel better, and most were just happy that I was adding something back in.
The true and honest real talk is that I *did* feel better once I added eggs to my diet. My digestion improved drastically, not because of the eggs, per se, but because I was eating less fiber. Let me say that again: I did not feel better because the eggs worked some miracle, they just replaced other protein sources that were irritating to my guts.
In the nine months that I ate eggs I learned a ton about fermenting, soaking, sprouting, and cooking with kombu to make grains and beans more digestible. I wasn’t paralyzed by stress and fear of eating (which totally messes up my stomach) and was able to get into a healthier mind set around food. At some point, I got a “weird” egg from my farmers market (it was too gross to go into detail about here) and I was just done. I realized I had gathered the tools to get a vegan diet to be more digestible for me, and that even if I didn’t eat meat and dairy, and even if I was getting the most compassionate eggs possible, they were still an animal product, and I am grossed out by consuming things produced by animals. My slide back into veganism was easy, and it felt like home.
What didn’t feel like home, was the backlash I got from (some of) the vegan community while I was gone. People assumed I was eating fully Paleo, that I had gotten sucked into the “Crossfit dogma” and was “one of them” now (C’mon guys, really? us vs. them? Not cool.) My face was put on a website called exvegans.com (which started as a database of ex-vegans and quickly turned to graphic carnage shots of factory farming- I have not linked to the site because I don’t really recommend anyone support the people who made it). The description of me simply read “Lacy Davis- ex vegan. Now has a weird obsession with eggs.” I heard through the grapevine that many people thought of me as disingenuous and a traitor because I was no longer vegan. Ouch.
As I said, I did come back to veganism and I am all the happier for it. My digestion continues to remain strong with just a little extra effort, and a good chunk of my work with Super Strength Health is helping people go and stay vegan. While I remain dismayed at the poor treatment I received from parts of the vegan community, I am super clear that those people were not and will never be my people, and that ultimately, it is incredibly important for our compassion to of course include animals, but also humans. Some of them are struggling, and for all the righteousness that moral outrage may produce when it comes to ex-vegans, it simply doesn’t help.
I have been, and will continue to be, vegan for the love. My lapse taught me that more than anything, my diet has to feel safe and healthy for me, while remaining compassionate. It is completely and totally possible to remain vegan THROUGH various illnesses, but it might take some tweaking, trial and error, and even a break.
I choose to be one of the vegans that will be here if and when an ex-vegan decides to come back.
This post reminded me of a quote from Colleen Patrick-Godreau that my friend Natalia shared recently:
“You don’t get a certificate of purity when you become vegan. If you’re looking for perfection (in yourself or others), you have forgotten that being vegan is about manifesting compassion- not a means to becoming 100% pure. There is no such thing in our imperfect world. The animals need us to aspire compassion, not perfection. Do not do nothing because you can’t do everything. Do something. Anything.”
That’s beautiful. I think we can all do a damn lot without being perfect.
<3 this post. Very well said. At the end of the day, we have to be compassionate and loving, even when we don't agree with people. And thank you for sharing your journey with us.
Thank you for being a not so judgmental vegan! haha. I have to say, your blog name may be slightly false advertisement :)
I was vegan, I am not any more. I may be again, That is all.
totally. it’s chill, people!
This is so beautiful and real. Your voice is a gift to the blogosphere.
I have never changed any hearts or minds with being a mean vegan. I have learned that interacting with others with complete non-judegement is far more powerful than being a dick. People have gone vegan after knowing me and attributing their transition to the fact that I just led by example and didn’t shove it in their face. That’s what I strive to do around non-vegans and/or ex-vegans alike. It works so much better!
Thanks, girl! That’s a mega compliment coming from you! You are my blog role model!
Hi Lacy, i’m a volunteer for VeganMoFo and I understand the purpose of the egg photo but we have a rule about no non-vegan food photos during the event (sometimes non-vegans participate) because it upsets people, so would you mind taking it down? Thanks!
Sure! I am totally sorry to be a rule breaker. I am not exactly a fine-print-reader. All taken care of now, and much respect.
THANK YOU for writing this. I’ve always made a point of telling others that I eat vegan, I prefer to eat vegan, etc… instead of identifying myself as a vegan. For me, it is a really important distinction, because eating this way is something I do and something I choose to do, and it’s something anyone can choose to do at any meal. I really appreciate your radical honesty, and you are so articulate about your story and how you landed on what works so well for you now. I also really like Colleen’s take on perfectionism and veganism as others mentioned.
totally. I also think taking the pause TOTALLY renewed my commitment to veganism and shifted it back towards something i choose on a daily basis.
This is a great post. I have been saddened by some of the popular bloggers that have come out as ex-vegans, but I have been mortified much more by the comments and backlash they have received.
seriously. I am hoping that we can all get a little more compassionate. I have to say though, if you have never been in a situation to question if the diet is healthy for you, its easier to be mad! I learned a lot from my time away.
[…] That One Time I Was An Ex-Vegan by Lacy Davis at Super Strength Health […]
Thank you for writing this post! It’s great to see that you were able to return to the vegan lifestyle, despite some very serious health concerns. Most of my friends and family are omnivores (with a few vegetarians and pescetarians mixed in). So I definitely see vegetarianism, such as you displayed when you were struggling with your IBS, as a positive thing. Any step towards less animal cruelty is awesome!
I don’t understand how some vegans can be so accusatory towards ex-vegans. (I guess maybe they might feel defensive because some ex-vegans suggest there is a problem with their lifestyle or inherent deficiency in their diet. – NOT in your case, I should add.) If veganism doesn’t work for someone else, that’s unfortunate, but please be compassionate towards humans as well. Less than 1% of the population is vegan/plant-based, so we’re the minority, and we need to behave in a way that inspires others to do more research into food production practices and their personal health and possibly consider veganism or vegetarianism. Hate and striking out against non-vegans just turns people away.
I’m a big fan of Sayward at Bonzai Aphrodite, and I’m so glad she linked over to your post! Thanks for sharing your story!
thank you for reading! I am just about to hop over to your blog and hear about your 90 day vegan challenge! Very exciting.
Thanks! I’ve actually been vegan for a little over a year now. It started out as a 90 day challenge, and I just kept going. My blog is now called “Run, VegGirl, Run” changed from the original “My 90 Day Vegan Challenge”, but I haven’t wanted to change the url, yet.
Also, thanks for the egg link-up! I’ll definitely make use of that for my husband, who is still an omnivore. (I like to buy him products with better animal welfare ratings instead of the cheap stuff he usually buys by default.)
Thank you for sharing this. I actually found your blog through a response you left on another blog about the whole “ex-vegan” phenomenon. I can relate to so much of what you have written. I grew up in Alabama, live in Georgia. Meat is big here. So is hunting. Any time I wear my “KALE” sweatshirt, someone stops me to talk about it. I had been leaning vegetarian for 2 years when I got pregnant, then decided to raise my son vegetarian, and I took holy heck (from friends and family!) for that decision. I have done vegan for short intervals, usually because meat consumption just kills my tummy. I decided to “go vegan” in August of last year, and I admit that I have struggled to find balance. I battled bulimia for much of my 20s, and I find the restricting feeling I sometimes get with veganism tends to trigger old habits. I am also a runner and anemic. SO, I call myself vegan. I use terms like “plant powered”. The truth is, I may eat meat (beef) once per month (if that). I don’t really crave chicken at all. Sometimes I crave tuna, which I think is a protein issue. I find that mentally, keeping that option open keeps my disordered thoughts/habits at bay, and physically sometimes I really do feel like I need it. (I get it from a local farm about 45 minutes away.)
What gets me is the negativity I have encountered from “hardcore” or “real” vegans. It’s much worse than any criticism I received from omnis. My thinking is, am I not doing all that I can? Has my awareness not increased along with my compassion? I mean, come on. 30 years of eating meat, I can’t just turn it all off like a faucet. What should be demanded of someone, but that they do the very best they can? Which I am doing. So anyway I don’t really say “vegan” anymore, and where I used to like to talk about food, I tend to shrink from those conversations these days. I am having to figure it out, nutrition wise, because I have had stomach and sleep issues. But reading this made me hopeful, and I’m encouraged by your “judge not” stance.
[…] Some time ago, I wrote about my time as an ex-vegan. […]
Hi Lacy, I admit I was a little disappointed when you told me you were no longer vegan and were eating eggs (especially since you were one of those inspiring me to go all vegan!), but I get it of course! Personal health is far more important than veganism so I definitely understand.
Reading this makes me even more happy especially since you found the wonders of fermentation and other “tricks” to digesting vegetable matter (been making my own soy yogurt lately, especially after soyyogurtmageddon, RIP WholeSoy). And I’m really glad to see you’re writing again!
Mine and perhaps a lot people’s beef (heh) with “Paleo” is how amazingly non-scientific it is. Having a couple degrees in anthropology helps to see this, of course. There are certainly some tenants it’s brought to popularity (namely, that animals [that’s us too!] should eat the diets they’ve evolved to eat), but then sorta fails at defining what diet is the “real” human diet. Boil that down into sound bites and assumptions and you’ve got a best seller!
RE: the ex-vegan hate. I don’t condone overt hatred and I can’t believe there’s a website like that (tho now it just forwards to a youtube video). However I feel that veganism needs to have both “good cops” (“plant-based” diet, vegan analogs of meaty-cheesy, etc) and “bad cops”, which would be the political aspects of being vegan. I sorta hate that there’s a whole slew of new restaurants specifically avoiding the word vegan and using instead “plant-based” so that no one needs to understand the sociopolitical and animal rights advocacy side of not eating animals, but I get it and begrudgingly accept it as part of a two-pronged attack!
Of course, maybe I’m just bitter all my formerly vegan friends (but they are still my friends!) aren’t any longer and not for really profound reasons, sigh…
Anyway, Hi!
HI JESSE!
I was kind of a secret hater of “plant based” but then i realized that i don’t have to hate it, i can just know that that label is not me. Plant-based (to me!) is about what one eats, but veganism is about ethics. Not that a person who identifies as one or the other can’t choose WHY, but that seems to be the distinction as far as I can tell. I am crossfitter, so many paleo-ish folks at my gym identify as plant based while still eating a fair amount of meat. Its just a kind of non-descriptive name, so meh! whatevs. Not my thang.
I have been trying to make soy yougurt for eons, but I ALWAYS fuck it up. Tell me your ways!
This is amazing! After being vegan for around 2 years I find myself in the same spot you were in… I developed a stomach ulcer about a month ago and while I nearly healed it vegan, it seemed like it would last for a day or two before I would slip up and eat something that would reopen the wound.
I read up on gut healing diets, and all of them said the same basic thing… No grains, no beans.
So I thought, what the hell am I supposed to do to feel full? Eat a lot of nuts, which are high in phytates and risk other nutrient malabsorption? Nuts had been causing digestive upset in me already though, so it became clear that I had to make a change or else I would be sacrificing my health for the sake of vegan ism.
But honestly now, if all the vegans look and feel like shit (which was me towards the end) how do you expect to win more people over by encouraging them to be more conscious of their food choices? Huh? If veganism isn’t sexy then significantly less people will even consider going there in the first place. And this world needs more people to gain this consciousness because our resources are running out fast, as the population grows larger…
So, I went to the store and bought some pasture raised eggs, cooked some up, then went on Craigslist to find a far, fresh source of eggs 15 minutes away from me.
Because here’s the thing. I don’t have a moral problem with eggs at all, that are not factory farmed! They’re chicken periods, they happen every day and if they don’t get eaten then that’s food gone to waste! I care most about sustainability, and I don’t see the logic in standing up on a soapbox talking down to people instead of just reaching down and grabbing the egg that will rot if it is not eaten.
It has been a few days now and I feel much better. My omega 3 levels were depleted by a lot I think, and ugh I just love eggs so much and I can’t believe I was denying myself this pleasure! And I’m so excited.
I still don’t feel it is ethical to drink cows milk, not to mention store bought milk is a very far cry from the really good stuff, from real raw fresh milk ( which I have only had a few times in my life), that come from sad cows who are being violated, used for their product…
So yeah fuck dairy… And meat. If I do eat meat again I would kill it myself, blessing it with thanks in a way similar to native Americans. But as of now I don’t have the balls to kill an animal so I have no right to eat it.
Just my two cents. Eggs kick ass!